Elevated view of a white stucco single-story house with a gray shingle roof, broad front lawn, concrete driveway and a copper-barked specimen tree.

Paragon Theaters at Mercato: What's Changing in North Naples

On September 8, there were 21 movie screens where US-41 meets Vanderbilt Beach Road. Alamo Drafthouse ran 11 on the second floor at Mercato, and Paragon Theaters ran 10 across the highway at The Pavilion. After Alamo's last night on September 9, only Paragon's 10 were left.

Mercato's empty cinema has already found its next tenant, and it's the company across the street. Paragon will run both theaters once Mercato reopens. It plans to close four of its Pavilion screens when that happens, so the total will settle at 17. North Naples gets its second theater back with fewer screens than it had a season ago, all under one operator.

The Count, Before and After

Period Mercato, 2nd floor The Pavilion Total screens
Through Sept. 9, 2026 11, Alamo Drafthouse 10, Paragon 21
Now through the holidays Dark until Paragon opens 10, Paragon 10
Paragon's stated goal once Mercato opens 11, Paragon 6, Paragon 17

Michael Whalen, Paragon's co-CEO and co-owner, explained the target to Naples Press:

"The goal is to have 17 screens functioning in Naples. That's where we want to be. We think that's the sweet spot."

In the same interview, he said the company is "trying to rationalize the screens in the marketplace." The table follows from that. Paragon is sizing North Naples by total screen count and splitting that total between the two buildings it will run.

Why Mercato's Second Floor Keeps Changing Hands

The Mercato cinema has had three operators in about 17 years, and the last change came quickly.

  1. September 2009. Silverspot opens at Mercato and runs for nearly 14 years.
  2. July 2023. Silverspot's lease expires and isn't renewed, and the theater closes.
  3. April 29, 2024. Alamo Drafthouse opens its first Florida location in the same space, with 11 dine-in auditoriums, a full menu, a bar, and a nine-hole mini golf course.
  4. Within months. Sony Pictures Experiences acquires Alamo shortly after the Naples opening, and the mini golf is eventually removed.
  5. September 4, 2026. Alamo announces the closing. Gulfshore Business reported that the company called Naples an underperforming location.
  6. September 9, 2026. Alamo's last day. Naples Season Pass members get prorated refunds, and Alamo offers employees severance and help finding jobs with Paragon.
  7. October 21, 2026. Mercato's leasing agent announces that Paragon has signed for the 33,700-square-foot space, with an opening expected in early 2027.

Even in its closing statement, Alamo said it was "relieved to know that the building will continue operating as a movie theater under Paragon Theaters." Lauren Ness, a spokesperson for Jamestown, which leases and manages Mercato, told Gulfshore Business that "entertainment continues to be an important part of our vision for the property." So Mercato kept its movie theater, and the operator on both sides of the highway is now the same company.

Four Screens at The Pavilion Make Way

The screens Paragon plans to give up at The Pavilion, 833 Vanderbilt Beach Road, aren't in the main theater. They're in a separate 9,850-square-foot freestanding building at the back of the center's northwest corner, connected to the main theater by a hallway near the bar.

That building has changed back and forth before. Whalen walked Naples Press through it. The site started as a 10-screen theater, then shrank to six when Tuesday Morning took part of the space. Paragon leased the six-screen theater, and when the Tuesday Morning space opened up again, it went back to 10. When Paragon Pavilion opened on May 1, 2014, after a renovation of nearly $3 million, the Naples Daily News described six auditoriums with leather recliners and a bar-and-restaurant lounge. The plan now takes the Pavilion back to six.

Nobody has decided what goes in next. Andrew Pressler, a leasing agent for The Pavilion's owner, Regency Centers, told Naples Press the owner has "the option, the potential, to take back the old Tuesday Morning box" and lease it to another tenant, but added that "nothing's really fleshed out completely." Whalen mentioned interest from an indoor soccer operator and from the cycle shop already in the center, which might want the space for inventory. He also floated keeping it himself for about six golf simulators. He pointed out that the building already has the kitchen, bar, and restrooms a simulator business would otherwise have to build.

For now, the main theater still serves MyPi pizzas, concession food, beer, wine, and liquor, according to Paragon's Pavilion menu.

What Paragon Is Building at Mercato

Mercato is getting the full version of Paragon's format, and that helps explain why the Pavilion can shrink. According to Naples Press, the 11 screens will have:

  • Lux Box seating, Paragon's heated recliners with full table service
  • MyPi Pizza, the in-house brand, with dough made fresh daily
  • A full bar serving craft cocktails, wine, and beer
  • Two Axis15 Extreme large-format auditoriums with tilted screens, 4K laser projection, and Dolby Atmos sound
  • The Director's Room, a private theater you can rent for screenings, game-watching parties, or company events
  • Pricing in line with Paragon's other nearby locations, including $5 Ticket Tuesdays

Whalen has made Lux Box the deciding factor for opening day. He told Naples Press he won't open Mercato until every auditorium has those seats, because Lux Box is "the biggest feature we have." Paragon is also hiring for several positions at Mercato.

The Holidays Run Through The Pavilion

Paragon's schedule depends on two big December releases. Whalen's target was to open Mercato by December 18, when the sequels to The Avengers and Dune come out. If the seats were delayed, he told Naples Press, "it's probably a beginning of January event now." Mercato's announcement on October 21 said early 2027, and the Naples Daily News reported the same timing.

Paragon said it would keep the Pavilion's four rear screens running through the end of the year, which means 10 screens through the holidays. Whalen put it this way: "We'll continue to operate the 10 screens at Naples through the holiday." So December's big releases in North Naples play at The Pavilion, and the switch to six screens comes after that.

Next year's film festival is where the split shows up first. The Naples International Film Festival ran October 22 to 25 this year, with screenings at Paragon Pavilion and closing-night events at Artis—Naples. Whalen said next year's festival could go to either theater. He described Mercato as "a little bit higher-end for the film festival people." With only six screens, he said, the festival could rent the whole Pavilion and run it with no other movies showing. Either way, Paragon will be the host.

Changes at Mercato and The Pavilion affect daily life in North Naples, and they come up in our conversations with buyers and sellers who live nearby. If you're thinking about what's next for your home near US-41 and Vanderbilt Beach Road, The S Group would be glad to talk it through with you. Schedule your free consultation.

Let’s Get Started

Partner with Aline Smolanoff and experience a real estate process built on trust, expertise, and personalized care. Whether you’re buying, selling, or investing, we are ready to guide you toward your goals with confidence.

Follow Us on Instagram